I prefer the aromatics of the 2005

but with more time in bottle

pear and wet stone where the latter element continues onto the rich

there is a minor sensation of green flavors

The palate is very charming and superbly vinous

Vincent Girardin, Bienvenues Batard Montrachet Vintage:2005 I prefer the aromatics ofDiscreet wood frames honeysuckle and white flower aromas and continues onto the rich, full and quite (naturally) sweet medium bodied flavors that are both classy and stylish and wrapped in a forward, accessible and round finish that offers admirable length. Still, as good as this is, it seems almost flat after the impressive punch and drive of the Quintessence. 92 2009+